Friday, May 23, 2025

My Italian Wars Reading List... so far!

As with any new project a large part of the joy is in the learning.  Here is a selection of the reading I've done.  The following are readily available.

The first and certainly the "must read" tome is Oman.  A great read in itself regardless of any particular interest in the period.  Infinitely re-readable.


The Italian Wars by Shaw and Mallet.  I found this a very good history of the wars.  It is certainly a confusing period with many shifts of alliances.  However, the survey of the wars is well covered.  So, with pen and notebook to hand, I made sense of events, people and chronology.  I would certainly recommend this.


Weapons and Warfare in Renaissance Europe by Bert Hall.  I found this to be an eye opening book.  I thought that I knew some stuff about gunpowder and firearms, but Hall has really made me think hard about the use and efficacy of gunpowder and firearms. Not just in the 16th century, but right through to the early 1800s.


Of course, the editions from Helion and Osprey are bread and butter and offer invaluable material.




One of the primary sources I looked at was the commentaries from Blaise de Monluc.  Whilst his memoirs are self serving they provide an insight into events, people and how they fought.  For the small action or skirmish gamer, there are some accounts in here that lend themselves to the tabletop.


I'll round off this brief survey of my reading with this wargamer's guide to the Italian Wars by Cairns and Ashton, recently published by Helion.


It's good. Well and sensibly organised. The history is concise but useful. The section on armies of the different states and their organisation was welcome and gave enough information to think about the differences. The scenarios were usefully set out in a straightforward way which seemed genuinely rule agnostic.  They included 15 scenarios from Fornovo, Cerignola, through Pavia and to Gravelines. The painting section reminded me of one I am sure that I found from a blog post somewhere.  However, it's helpful on getting started on both landsknechts and gendarmes.  Some period designs for the latter might of been a good addition.  Although the information on damask designs was surprisingly engaging.  The bibliography is extensive and means that further research can be carried on productively.   All in all a great buy... in my opinion.

However, I wonder if for anyone already immersed in the period this will add to their understanding and hobby knowledge.  But then, I suppose the audience is probably more for people like me who have just recently embarked on this period. 

Being a little pedantic for a moment, the irritant for me was what seems to be the lack of proofreading and editing. Many pages (and I do mean a lot) have either poor spelling, typos or a nonsensical sentence.  I'm no shining example of accurately written English but I did, at times, find myself looking for them instead of taking in the information. 

Nonetheless, I am still extremely happy that I purchased this addition to the Helion library.  The authors should be congratulated on, what I found to be, a well organised, informative and really useful guide to wargaming the period.

Enough of the review of "All is Lost, Save Honour."

To those immersed in the period apologies for highlighting the obvious.  To everyone else, I hope this gives a nice sense of my early knowledge accumulation.



23 comments:

  1. Thorough collection of books, I really liked the Mallet and Shaw book, there's a good book in the siege of Rome that's inexpensive and worth a read and of course the borgias were running the papacy at the beginning of this period, I'll have a look over the weekend and see if there is anything else that might be worth getting, oh and the painting guide for the Helion book was done by the chap who has the the army royal blog, a fantastic painter who's guide to painting landsknechts blog I used when I started painting them .Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes, that's the blog I found. I also extracted the painting guide for landsknecht and promptly forget where I got it from. I, too, use it.
      Any book recommendations would be greatly appreciated Iain. The Mallet and Shaw book is definitely a good reference.

      Delete
  2. Blimey that's quite a lot of reading you have done! You have certainly done your research, and I'm sure it will be seriously useful to your project. I know almost nothing about this period, though I did read Monluc many years ago. The Oman book is on my 'Jenga pile of shame'..

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks David. You must carefully extract Oman and make a start. It's possible tp read the bits that interest you then dip back in another time if you wish.

      Delete
  3. Wow that is a fair collection of books Richard! This period seems to be very popular at the moment, so looking forward to seeing your painting continue of the extremely colourful troops involved!

    ReplyDelete
  4. That is a decent collection of books. The Italian Wars really seem to be very popular at the moment

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. 500th anniversary of Pavia certainly helps.

      Delete
  5. That's a lot of reading on a short time Rich! Good on ya!

    ReplyDelete
  6. A very nice selection of books there Richard:). Oman is a great read, no matter the period he is covering. Some of it probably a bit dated now, but a superb starting point for any period. As for Helion and proof reading, don't get me started!!! I did consider this book but now definitely not as this would put me off no end. Maybe Ken Riley's book instead, to go on the presents list?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. LOL. It's still a good volume, but the edit can be a distraction. I'll have to look out for Ken Riley's book. Do we have a title for it?

      Delete
    2. Italy's Honour and Liberty: A Guide to Wargaming the Great Italian Wars, 1494-1559: 24 (Helion Wargames) by Ken Riley. Currently Amazon is showing the same cover as the book you just bought, which is confusing!

      Delete
    3. I've just looked and found the same on a number of online book outlets. Confusing. Maybe someone can explain.

      Delete
    4. Cairn and Ashton’s book IS the book that Riley was slated to produce. Not sure what happened but these two gents stepped in to get this topic into publication.

      Richard, you have a good collection of books covering the period. I have most of them but not Cairn and Ashton. Predonzani now is up to five volumes plus one more on the Swabian War. I have a few more titles to add to your growing collection.

      Delete
    5. Thanks for the clarification Jonathan. I very much look forward to your reading recommendations.

      Delete
    6. Thanks for clearing this up Jon! The confusing thing is the Amazon listing shows a publication date of 2021, some images of the 'original' cover online, but nothing on the Helion website.

      Delete
  7. Some great recommendations there Richard, and a few I'll now look to pick up before I start on my 15mm Italian Wars project.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Looking forward to seeing your excellent paintwork on this colourful period.

      Delete
  8. Very good references - I need to acquire some for myself too!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, they are very helpful and informative.

      Delete
  9. Somehow the Italian Wars has never sparked my interest but I do have, and have read, the Oman, Hall and Blaise de Monluc as I am interested (only tempted, not committed) in the later French Wars of Religion.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Good taste Rob. Hopefully you've seen some of my 2mm posts on the French Wars of Religion. A fantastic period to game and learn about.

      Delete

Most Popular Posts