Wednesday, January 28, 2026

The Battle of Wakefield, 1460 - A War of the Roses AAR

Jonathan Freitag and I took to the remote gaming table to stretch our hands across the Atlantic and fight his interpretation of the War of the Roses Battle of Wakefield (see here for his details).

An in-play photo, courtesy of J. Freitag

I took command of the Yorkists while Jonathan led the Lancastrians.

The initial deployment.
Rutland's archers overseeing the wagons en route to the castle.  The Duke of York rushing out to engage the Lancastrians.

While the wagons move slowly, York's Battle advanced aggressively towards Somerset and the newly arrived Northumberland.

Yorkist reinforcements arrive in the guise of Salisbury and his Battle.

Meanwhile York, hoping to gain a swift advantage, charged Northumberland's troops.  However, things do not go to plan.  Northumberland repels York's efforts but his men force him to fall back to reorganise.  Somerset now crashed into York throwing him back further.  But at the moment of victory, Somerset is wounded and has to be carried from the field.

With Clifford having arrived on the field to support the Lancastrian left, Northumberland hurled his men at the Duke of York's faltering Battle.  The melee is brutal.  In the crush the Duke of York is struck down, dead!  York's Battle is now a broken unit.

Rutland's archers on the Yorkist left keeps up a constant rain of arrows but to limited effect as Somerset and Clifford move to strengthen the Lancastrian battle line.
Salisbury moves forward to support the remnants of York's tattered Battle and shield the creeping supply wagons.

Hoping to reverse the situation, Salisbury launched his men at arms into Northumberland's depleted Battle.  

Northumberland's men at arms are annihilated as Salisbury's warriors sweep forward.  However, little do they realise that in the swirl of melee Salisbury is struck down and mortally wounded.  Seeking to wipe out Northumberland, Salisbury's now leaderless troops pursue and crash into Somerset's men.  The Yorkists are thrown back at great loss...

... and back again as Somerset is relentless in the pursuit.

The remaining Yorkists are not given a chance to rallying as Somerset's men deal out more slaughter.  Salisbury's Battle breaks under the strain.

With two of the three Battles broken, the Yorkists flee the field.  This has been a disaster for the Yorkist cause.  Two leaders dead on the field.  One of them the Yorkist leader himself!

Afterthoughts
By choosing to play the Yorkists, I knew that this was going to be a very tough battle to get a victory.  However, that did not stop this game being a tremendous amount of fun.  The challenge was to better the Yorkist performance.  Alas, I believe history was repeated.

A thoroughly enjoyable game.  Well done, Jonathan.


21 comments:

  1. Great looking game Richard, A loss can be made into a win, if yu had fun playing the game!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Excellent, the game had a good rhythm to it and the loss of 2 very notable leaders is significant falling out from the action. The Yorkists have the tougher game as is right if simulating the actual battle, so I suppose the ‘win’ is not to do as badly as they did historically :-) and more to the point as Ray said - having fun brings its own win.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Norm. Jonathan puts on a good game. I do enjoy the challenge of the assymetric battles.

      Delete
  3. You take good notes, Richard! Excellent recap of the action. Had York not lost that initial clash against Northumberland, York may have saved himself and his throne. Well, perhaps not, but the odds for success may have shifted a bit. This was a good, sharp scrap, and much fun. Thank you! You definitely had the much more difficult task. With Rutland still alive at end of battle, I say you bettered the historical outcome.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you, Jonathan. Your game was enormous entertainment.
      Are you suggesting that on my historical conditions give me a victory?

      Delete
    2. No, not really! Seeing Rutland escape with his head suggests that you bettered the historical outcome.

      Delete
  4. Replies
    1. Thanks, Michal. Jonathan puts on a good show.

      Delete
  5. An excellent game and a brutal encounter for the Yorkists

    ReplyDelete
  6. Always a tough ask for the House of York, but you certainly did your level best to reverse history:)!

    ReplyDelete
  7. I was following the slow progress of the wagons with great interest, cheering them on and wondering if they were going to make it to safety. It looks like a fun game.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have confess, Lawrence, that I was willing them on a bit faster.

      Delete
  8. Great looking game- WOTR is such a great period to play.

    ReplyDelete
  9. Great looking game, I dont know what else you could do in this asymetrical scenario, you were just missing a little luck?
    Best Iain

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I really enjoyed it Iain. A little bit of luck at the start might have made a little difference.

      Delete
  10. Lovely looking table and a great game Richard - maybe you could have moved York up, so his left was anchored on the Y fork in the road and waited for Salisbury to come up on your right, while using the archers on the road to harass the Lancastrians? I don't have any other suggestion on a strategy for the Yorkists to win this battle, it looks pretty hard for them!

    ReplyDelete

Most Popular Posts