Monday, April 11, 2022

A Little Reading - The French Wars of Religion

We all like to know what we are getting into when we start a new project.  This will involve film, books, an increasing amount of online media and source material.

The French Wars of Religion is unusual as a wargaming project for me.  All my periods have found their origins in my teaching them at school.  Drawing inspiration as I extended and deepened my understanding of the topics in order to better convey the history to my students.  I have never taught the French Wars of Religions.  In this respect, the research has been a more personal and "selfish" endeavour.

My research process tends to start with simple (often children's books) then work up to more specialist/detailed work.  I find that this helps me to build the layers of knowledge and not become overwhelmed by information.  However, there aren't many English language children's books on this topic!

Here are some of the books I've read so far.

General history

Years of Renewal is an old textbook for A (advanced) level students in the UK (17-18 years).  It surveys the period stated.

It takes themes and countries into account, and ensures that the whole are connected.

It is an easy read and doesn't get you bogged down in too much detail.  It is well organised.  It has to be remembered that this is aimed at students.

Nonetheless, I found it useful as one of my starting points.  Little by way of military history... as you might expect.





This is another student textbook.  This comes from a series that covers A level and early university students.  This series contains extracts from primary sources as integral to the reading.

Very much focusing on the complex factors at play during the wars - economic, factions, social, religious etc.

Robert Knecht has published a number of items on this period and clearly is a master of his material.

Again, not a military history but essential in getting a handle on the context, and very readable.









Detailed History

This is an excellent narrative/analysis of European history from the Treaty of Cateau-Cambresis to the Treaty of Vervins.

It provides a detailed account that makes clear the interwoven strands of events, characters and developments.  From England to Poland, and Sweden to Spain.  Europe gets covered and the links are revealed.

In a readable fashion a lot of complexity is carefully handled and transmitted.

It is not a military history.  However, it does a good job in showing that the French civil wars are inextricably linked to events in Elizabethan England, the Netherlands, Rome and all of them inevitably with Spain.



I've put this volume from Osprey Publishing under detailed history as, whilst it gives a very good treatment of the wars and all the major battles, it also provides good and clear history and context.

This follows the usual pattern for Osprey books and is well illustrated.

A good read and helpful companion.  But for deeper understanding of the wars in context, rather than military alone, then Knecht's book above is more appropriate.







The wars and the military

Sorry.  This is a hardback book and I lost the dust cover.

This is a general survey of war in the sixteenth century.  There are some comments on a few battles, but it is really about how wars were fought.

This is almost a coffee table type of book - easy to pick up, have a peek at some pictures, read a little portion, then put down.  Having said that, it is actually very revealing in the art of war and formations used.

I think that this is a very useful book and a nice starter on the art of war in this period.





Again.  No dust cover on this book!  I'm clearly quite careless.

This one is specifically aimed at wargamers.  Gush may be a name that older gamers will recognise.

Divided by country/empire this deals with the various troop types and, broadly speaking, how they fought.

Very useful black and white photos and drawings of troops, armour and flags.  You can always find something new in here.

Quite a valuable tome to have in one's collection.





A small paperback guide.  This covers in brief detail the major battles of the wars.  There is a map with deployments and enough information to start compiling orders of battles for each of the engagements.  There is a little background information with each.  However, the focus is, as the title suggests, a wargamer's guide.


No colour illustrations here, or fancy printing.  This is good old fashioned fare.  Nonetheless, a good job well done to get you started.











This one is from Helion publishing and still quite new.  It is excellent.  A really good primer for the wargamer.

It has some background context.  There is sufficient detail on the major battles of the wars, maps with plenty of information to start organising your armies and games.  Plus, there are colour and black and white illustrations of various troop types and standards.

It can feel a little quirky in its use of old French for town names, but this does not detract from the really handy nature of this volume.

There are plenty of prints from the time and the bibliography permits deeper investigation.

An essential purchase in my view.



Another absolutely essential read is this one by Charles Oman.  There are aspects of this that is a little dated, e.g. the treatment of some of the historical characters.  However, this is a classic and remains a "buy it now" volume.

The section on the French Wars of Religion is brilliant for understanding the troops, the tactics and how the wars were fought.  It always nicely links to the other conflicts that are also covered, such as the Dutch rebellion against Spain.









Next Steps

I'm looking to start examining the more contemporary accounts of people like Tavannes, La Noue or Montluc.  Hopefully I can find English translations before I have to put my very limited French to the test!!



15 comments:

  1. Excellent survey. Interesting that you begin will children's books.
    Arnold, Gush, Oman, and Knecht are all in my library and they are useful additions, for sure.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thank you Jonathan. I try to work on the principle of start simple then build up.

      Delete
  2. Thanks for the book recommendations Richard, very useful should the need arise. I'd love to get Oman's book but the last time I checked it was, IMHO, being sold at silly prices:(.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have a second copy if shipping wouldn’t be prohibitive.

      Delete
    2. Thanks for the kind offer Jon, but now some copies have become available at decent prices:).

      Delete
    3. Glad you're able to get your copy Steve.

      Delete
  3. A grest post Richard, there are some really interesting books there. Even I've got 2 of them!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheers Ray. Let's hope the reading translate into great games.

      Delete
  4. George Gush wrote some great books, and a terrific set of rules which I still have on my bookshelf. How appropriate to have the surname "Knecht" and to be writing on 16th Century France.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Yes Lawrence, it's like he was destined to write on this subject.

      Delete
  5. That is an impressive array of books Richard....have you read them all? Mind you, I forgot that your planning and preparation phase has lasted several years, so you probably have! I must a it, it's a period of history I know next to nothing about...plucky Huegenot Protestants being assailed by dastardly Papists....isn't that the gist of it all....!!! Apologies if anyone is offended by my tongue in cheek sectarian oversimplification 🙂

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks. I have read them, and as you say I have had the time.

      Delete
  6. Yes, as Keith said, an impressive collection of material on the subject. I may someday venture into the period - using existing ECW figures.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Dean. Sounds like a plan in the making.

      Delete
  7. That's a good looking collection of books that should give you a range of views and perspectives. The background reading about a period is a big part of the interest in the hobby isn't it?
    Regards, James

    ReplyDelete