Tuesday, January 30, 2024

The Battle of Madonna dell'Olmo - AAR

The Rejects happily accepted Jon's, of Palouse Wargaming Journal, invitation to fight this battle.

For a fuller and much better introduction to the battle I refer you to Palouse Wargaming Journal: Assessing Victory Conditions.

Along with Surjit, I would attempt to further the Franco-Spanish cause.

The Austro-Sardinian forces were led by Lee and Steve.

What follows is the view of the game from my side of the table.  Such was the quality and immersive nature of the game that I cannot vouch for my accuracy.

The Austro-Sardinians started with the initiative, meaning they could move and engage with two brigades. This Franco-Spanish inability to snatch the initiative would be a constant thorn in the side throughout the game.

Surjit and I figured that we could not win by holding key points on the table.  So, our approach to the battle was to defend, use reserve orders where possible, and try to inflict significant losses on the Austro-Sardinians.

Deployed and ready to play.

Steve went straight onto the attack.  Surjit was consequently thrown out of Madonna dell'Olmo after a lengthy struggle. The enemy advanced to support their gains and threaten our right.

On our left, de Courrier's cavalry repositioned itself to counter any attempt by Lee to pass over the ditch.

Positions start of turn 2

La Mina (Surjit) faced a lot of pressure around Madonna dell'Olmo and held off an assault on Pasquale.
A lot of Franco-Spanish units are placed on reserve.  With Jonathan using his two green dice mechanism to produce an certain turn lengths and activations, it was important to be able to move when needed.  As it happened this was vital to de Courier's brigade as it would only be activated twice during the whole game, and so needed the reserve status to charge later.

Positions start of turn 3

The Austro-Sardinians continued their pressure on our right. They launched a successful assault on Pasquale, bringing numbers to bear.



However, Surjit massed his cavalry and gave the enemy a taste of our steel.  Pasquale was back in our hands.

Pasquale recaptured.

Whilst the fighting was on the right, the Austro-Sardinians were creeping round into the centre.

Positions start of turn 4

The battle on the right was becoming attritional. But on the left the Austro-Sardinians were now making moves on our left. Their artillery fire there was also inflicting casualties.

Positions start of turn 5

With Lee's troops advancing to occupy the centre, reserves from Camposanto's and de Courier's brigades (both played by me!) were hurled into a swirl of melee.  And in true epic wargaming fashion every single one was my units were either beaten or destroyed.  The Franco-Spanish left was starting to look very exposed.

Positions start of turn 6

Lee now made short work of destroying my best cavalry unit, taking Lupato farm and killing two leaders - Camposanto and de Courier. Our left was now more than just exposed... it had crumbled.

Positions at the end of the game.

The hour was late, my neatly pressed pyjamas and hot coco were awaiting my attention.  So it was that Surjit and I accepted the fact of an Austro-Sardinian minor victory.  

Well done to Lee and Steve who played an excellent game, and to Surjit who led a heroic defence of our positions on the right.  Alas, poor Surjit needed a better commander on the left, and certainly one who could throw some decent dice in a while.

Kudos to Jonathan for an extremely well crafted and challenging scenario, and to his quality umpiring.



23 comments:

  1. A great write up of a thoroughly enjoyable game. You were particularly unlucky with the dice last night (maybe sacrifice a goat to the dice gods before the next game??). Surjit and Dave must have been exhausted by the end as they were doing the bulk of the fighting the whole evening. As the evening progressed it was clear that Steve and I were being ground down through attrition, and I thought we were going to break and loose, so eeking out a minor victory felt like a huge achievement in the end.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Lee, it was a hard fought encounter but well played to you and Steve.

      Delete
  2. Excellent report, Richard! Thank you and the Rejects for participating. You fellas always make for a thoughtful and very enjoyable game for me. As Lee notes, you were a bit unlucky at times but if you really want the cavalry on the Left to get into the action, you must prioritize their activation to get them into the action.

    With the Austro-Piedmontese seeming to maintain the initiative throughout much of the battle, that result was much like the historical situation. The King exerted much more initiative than the Gallispans. Looking at the Dead Pile, your Franco-Spanish suffered much worse than the Austro-Piedmontese. I think a Minor Victory is a good result.

    Good game!

    Perhaps one day we can return to this battlefield for a rematch?

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks Jonathan.
      I think we both know that the priority for most of the game was on our right.
      I thought the green dice was an excellent mechanism.

      Delete
  3. It didn't seem as though you had much luck there Richard. From reading this and Jonathan's other reports it seems like a balanced and thoroughly engaging scenario.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Lady luck had definitely deserted me, but credit to my opponents... and Jon for a great scenario.

      Delete
  4. I enjoyed your report Richard. Sounds like Lady Luck wasn't with you. The game played out very differently on your left than in either of the games the group I'm in (we really must get a group name!).

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. I have been thinking your group needs a name too!

      Delete
    2. Thanks Chris. Lady Luck jilted me!
      I look forward to hearing your group name.

      Delete
    3. hmmm... like CSNY in the 70s? Foy, Nundanket, Ragged, Broom and St Cyr? Doesn't trip off the tongue, though..

      Delete
  5. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  6. Looked and read like a great tussle Richard - hopefully Jon will be able to add his perspective (if he has time between games and painting to fit it in!)

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. It was a hard and challenging struggle Keith... and very entertaining.

      Delete
  7. It did look a great and exciting game. Gutted I missed it, but as I were supposed to be on the Piedmontese side, I too will claim a minor victory....woo hoo!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Cheeky bugger. Your only victory will be a full recovery.

      Delete
  8. Sounds like you were a bit unlucky but still sounds like great fun!
    Best Iain caveadsum1471

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Outplayed as well. On my flank anyway. It was fun.

      Delete
  9. Good report and an interesting game - in our iterations of it, the 'Gallispans' tended to take a much more attacking approach, so this was quite a change, and perhaps you only suffered due to bad luck with the dice? Good stuff, anyway!

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Thanks David. Surjit and I took a conscious decision to soak up the pressure in the hope that the Austro-Sardinian tide would break against our rock... alas!

      Delete
  10. Great report there Richard and nice to compare it with Jon's AAR.

    ReplyDelete